E4 · cycle-003.e4-isr

Israel, scripted, 30 years from 1996

30 simulations of 30 rounds from the 1996 position. Israel decides by the scripted method; scripted events: Global funding seizure in year 4, Regional war spillover in year 10, Global funding seizure in year 12, Regional war spillover in year 18, Severe pandemic in year 24, Market access opening in year 24, Regional war spillover in year 27.

Model 0.2.0 · graph 0.2.0 · parameters 0.1.1 · seeds 1–30 · elasticity sampled within each bracket

The same configuration in other cycles: cycle 2.

Every simulation · Compare with another experiment · More experiments like this

Not a forecast
Simulations of a structural model with seed parameter values, to compare methods and test the model. Other nations stay at their 2026 ratings throughout.

Outcome across simulations

The median at 2026, with the 10th to the 90th percentile of the 30 simulations under it.

Capability index
15.80 (+0.66)
From 15.14; 15.78 to 15.84
Rank by index
7
From 11; 7 to 7
Domains at Tier 1
7
From 2; 7 to 7
Tier rank
2
From 9; 2 to 2

Capability index by round

Rank by index, by round

Every objective at the position and at the horizon
Objective199610th percentileMedian90th percentileBetter
Capability indexprimary15.1415.7815.8015.84higher
Rank by index11777lower
Tier rank9222lower
Domains at Tier 12777higher
Score sum1107.11164.01165.91167.9higher
Goal-weighted score1107.11164.01165.91167.9higher
Resilient score1107.11166.0 (mean score sum over the simulations)higher

The capability index is the mean of the three dimensions, each the mean of its domains, each the mean of its groups. Tiers are Pareto layers within each domain; the tier rank orders nations by domains held at Tier 1, then Tier 2, and so on. The goal-weighted score is the score sum unless the experiment sets a goal. The primary objective is the one the experiment is judged on; every other objective is reported beside it.

Credits

What each round’s credits went on in the median simulation. Across all simulations, build took 73 per cent, buy took 6 per cent, partner took 21 per cent of the 6,592 credits a simulation spent on actions.

Against history

Started from a reconstructed 1996 position and played along the pathway and shocks Israel actually had, then scored against the 2026 ratings. The position is an estimate, so part of any error is the reconstruction's. The calibration summary across all fifty nations is on the cycle's page under Loop.

Index 1996
15.14
reconstructed
Observed 2026
14.46
the Index's rating
Simulated 2026
15.80
15.72 to 15.91
Skill against persistence
−0.48
group error 2.12 against 1.43 if nothing changed
Domain1996ObservedSimulatedBiasDirection
Critical Technology12.7814.7515.86 15.8–15.9+1.11right
Strategic Infrastructure14.0613.8416.34 16.2–16.5+2.50wrong
National Security18.6316.2118.17 18.1–18.2+1.96right
Human Capital15.4315.0216.51 16.5–16.6+1.50wrong
Information & Influence14.4013.1214.20 14.1–14.3+1.08wrong
Governance & Integrity15.2614.2915.78 15.8–15.8+1.48wrong
Financial Strength15.0714.0315.65 15.6–15.7+1.62wrong
Production & Innovation15.5714.8915.28 15.2–15.4+0.38right
Trade & Investment15.1113.9414.44 14.3–14.8+0.50right

The history it was played under: shocks and events

  • 2000 · S02 × 0.6 The dot-com crash froze venture funding and triggered a high-tech recession, though no systemic banking crisis followed.
  • 2006 · S03 × 0.8 The Second Lebanon War brought sustained Hezbollah rocket fire on northern Israel and disrupted the economy for over a month.
  • 2008 · S02 × 0.5 The global financial crisis cut exports and overseas demand but Israel's banks and public finances remained broadly stable.
  • 2014 · S03 × 0.6 Operation Protective Edge brought Gazan rocket fire and brief economic disruption, though Iron Dome limited damage.
  • 2020 · S10 × 0.9 The COVID-19 pandemic forced repeated lockdowns and strained health services before Israel rolled out one of the fastest vaccination campaigns in the world.
  • 2020 · S12 × 0.4 The Abraham Accords normalised relations with the UAE, Bahrain, Morocco and Sudan, opening new trade, tourism and security cooperation.
  • 2023 · S03 × 1.3 The Hamas-led attack on 7 October and the ensuing Gaza, Lebanon and Iran conflict caused the worst single-day loss of life since 1948, mass mobilisation and severe economic disruption.

The pathway: what it prioritised, period by period

  • 1997–2000 · build · 2% each Yozma and the dot-com boom drove venture capital, chip design and communications start-ups while large-scale Russian immigration required technical retraining. (Semiconductors & Advanced Computing, Connectivity, Cyber & Trust Technologies, Business Dynamism & Entrepreneurship, Innovation & Commercialisation, Technical & Vocational Skills)
  • 2001–2005 · build · 5% each The Second Intifada and terrorist wave forced heavy spending on internal security, intelligence, and the West Bank barrier while keeping the high-tech sector afloat. (Land Power, Intelligence & Assessment, Cyber & Electromagnetic Operations, Internal Security & Order, National Resilience & Crisis Management)
  • 2006–2010 · build · 5% each The 2006 Lebanon War exposed rocket threats and triggered investment in Iron Dome and Arrow while macroeconomic reforms and export promotion preserved fiscal stability. (Air Power, Strategic Strike & Missile Defence, Fiscal Capacity & Public Finance, Financial Regulation & Integrity, Export Capability & Sophistication)
  • 2010–2015 · partner · 5% each Offshore natural gas discoveries at Tamar and Leviathan and national desalination projects shifted resources into energy and water security while the Israel Cyber Initiative expanded cyber capacity. (Energy Infrastructure, Resource Infrastructure, Energy Technologies, Water, Sanitation & Waste Infrastructure, Connectivity, Cyber & Trust Technologies)
  • 2015–2020 · build · 2% each The Innovation Authority and defence modernisation prioritised AI, autonomous systems and cyber exports while the Abraham Accords and new Asian markets broadened trade relationships. (Artificial Intelligence, Robotics & Autonomous Systems, Alliances & Security Cooperation, Trade Policy & Market Access, Digital & Services Trade)
  • 2020–2022 · build · 5% each COVID-19 triggered mass vaccination, digital health certificates and remote public services, strengthening biotech and national crisis response. (Health System Capability, Biotechnology & Health Technologies, Communications & Digital Infrastructure, National Resilience & Crisis Management, Digital & AI Competence)
  • 2023–2026 · buy · 5% each The 7 October 2023 attack and multi-front war forced a surge in munitions production, missile defence and reserve mobilisation, supplemented by large US security assistance. (Strategic Strike & Missile Defence, Air Power, Force Generation & Mobilisation, Cyber & Electromagnetic Operations, Intelligence & Assessment)

Reconstruction notes (deepseek-v4-pro): Scores for nuclear deterrence and intelligence are necessarily judgemental because of official opacity; the 1996 baseline for quantum and AI is uncertain because these fields were nascent and poorly measured. The mapping of repeated Israeli-Palestinian and Israeli-Hezbollah wars onto the event library's S03 regional-war spillover is an approximation, since no library event captures chronic asymmetric conflict.

Report

Written from the simulation record by the loop's narrator. Every figure names the query it came from, in square brackets.

Batch cycle-003. Model 0.2.0, graph 0.2.0, parameters 0.1.1. 30 simulations, seeds 1 to 30; probes on 10. Every figure is a distribution over simulations of a structural model with seed parameter values; it shows what the model implies under these settings, not what will happen. Other nations are frozen at their 2026 ratings. No reconstructed historical data is used in this experiment.

Headline

Israel played 30 rounds from 1996 under the scripted method, with scripted events, 30 times. Its capability index moved from 15.14 to a median of 15.80 (+0.66), with 90 per cent of simulations between 15.78 and 15.85 [experiment_objectives].

Starting position

In 1996 the nation ranks 11 on the index against the frozen field, holds 2 of nine domains at Tier 1 and has a tier rank of 9. Its base income is 1,433 credits a year, calibrated so that its 2026 position is affordable with headroom for investment.

What was decided

A simulation spent a median of 6,587 credits on moves. The five groups that took most were Energy Infrastructure (partner, 446 credits, 6.8 per cent); Resource Infrastructure (partner, 387 credits, 5.9 per cent); Financial Regulation & Integrity (build, 358 credits, 5.4 per cent); Strategic Strike & Missile Defence (build, 358 credits, 5.4 per cent); Fiscal Capacity & Public Finance (build, 358 credits, 5.4 per cent) [experiment_decisions_by_group]. By mode: build 73 per cent, partner 21 per cent, buy 6 per cent [experiment_decisions_by_group]. Concentration of spending (HHI) had a median of 0.052, and the most repeated action appeared in 20 per cent of rounds.

The leading domain by period: rounds 1 to 5, Production & Innovation; rounds 6 to 10, National Security; rounds 11 to 15, National Security; rounds 16 to 20, Strategic Infrastructure; rounds 21 to 25, Critical Technology; rounds 26 to 30, National Security [experiment_spend_by_period].

What the world did

A median simulation saw 6 shocks and 1 upside events. The most damaging per firing were S10 (30 firings in 30 simulations, −18.6 points each); S03 (90 firings in 30 simulations, −15.4 points each); S02 (60 firings in 30 simulations, −6.4 points each) [experiment_shocks]. Upside events fired 30 times across all simulations [experiment_shocks].

The groups that lost most to shocks, per simulation: Trade Facilitation & Logistics −2.74; Economic Leverage & Dependence −2.43; Fiscal Capacity & Public Finance −2.29; Labour & Employment −1.83 [experiment_shock_damage_by_group].

The edges that carried most change through the graph, per simulation: Fiscal Capacity & Public Finance to Force Generation & Mobilisation (+0.99 points); Fiscal Capacity & Public Finance to Social Infrastructure (+0.91 points); Artificial Intelligence to Robotics & Autonomous Systems (+1.09 points) [experiment_propagation_by_edge].

Where it ended

At 2026 the median rank is 7 (5th to 95th percentile 7 to 7), the median count of Tier 1 domains 7 (7 to 7) and the median tier rank 2; the resilient score, the mean score sum over simulations, is 1,166 [experiment_objectives].

Tier 1 probability changed most in: financial strength (0 to 100 per cent of simulations); governance and integrity (0 to 100 per cent of simulations); human capital (0 to 100 per cent of simulations); strategic infrastructure (0 to 100 per cent of simulations); trade and investment (0 to 100 per cent of simulations) [experiment_tiers_by_round].

Why

Without shocks the index ends +0.817 higher on average, so the shocks cost about 0.817 index points [experiment_probe_attribution].

Holding instead of following this method changes the index by −2.172: that is the method's worth against doing nothing [experiment_probe_attribution].

Removing any single one of the five largest actions changes the index by between 0.000 and +0.038, for example 2022 build Health System Capability (79 credits) [experiment_probe_attribution]. The largest actions by credits come late, when income is highest, and are rarely the most valuable.

Removing the largest shock of a simulation raises the index by +0.240 on average [experiment_probe_attribution].

The replay probe reproduces the simulations exactly (index change 0.000000), so the attributions are clean [experiment_probe_attribution].

Surprises

move_without_shock (warn): largest one-year move in a group with no shock landing: 4.45 points; 100% of simulations have one above 3.

saturation_high (warn): 100% of simulations end with a group at 20 that did not start there (median 2 groups).

retired_words (warn): e4-isr/report.md: 'simulations' 2 time(s), first near line 39; use 'simulations'.

The simulation furthest from the median (seed 4) ends +0.05 from it, with 6 shocks and 1 upside events [experiment_outlier_simulations].

Comparison

This is the baseline (hold) experiment, or there is none for this nation in the batch.

Against history: from a reconstructed index of 15.14 the model ends at 15.80, where the 2026 ratings put it at 14.46. Group scores miss by 2.12 points on average, against 1.43 for assuming nothing changed (skill −0.48); the change in each domain has the right sign in 44 per cent of domains. Furthest below history: production and innovation (+0.38); furthest above: strategic infrastructure (+2.50) [experiment_against_history]. The starting position is reconstructed, so part of the error is the reconstruction's.

What each decision and shock was worth

Counterfactual probes on the first 10 seeds: the same simulations with one thing changed, paired seed by seed. A removed decision or shock is taken out and the other decisions replayed unchanged, so the difference is that item's worth.

ProbeIndexScore sumTier 1For example
Hold instead of the method−2.172−165.9−6.00
No shocks+0.818+55.3+2.00
Replay of the recorded actions (must change nothing)0.0000.00.00
Without the 1st largest decision+0.000+0.20.002022 build Health System Capability (79 credits)
Without the 2nd largest decision+0.015+0.70.002015 partner Energy Infrastructure (78 credits)
Without the 3rd largest decision+0.011+0.6+0.202014 partner Energy Infrastructure (78 credits)
Without the 4th largest decision+0.013+0.60.002014 partner Resource Infrastructure (78 credits)
Without the 5th largest decision+0.038+2.6+0.202012 partner Energy Infrastructure (78 credits)
Without the 1st largest shock+0.195+12.1+1.002020 S10 (-18.6 points)
Without the 2nd largest shock+0.240+17.1+1.002023 S03 (-18.5 points)
Without the 3rd largest shock+0.185+12.7+0.602006 S03 (-18.0 points)

Simulations

Three simulations told round by round, each on its own page: the one nearest the median index at the horizon, and those nearest the 10th and the 90th percentile. Every one of the 30 is listed with its outcome on the simulations page.

All 30 simulations

Events

How often each shock and upside event began across the simulations. Shocks come from the ten downside scenarios and upside events from the ten upside ones, at their yearly likelihood.

Event
Kind
Simulations
Mean round
Points
Global funding seizure S02Shock100 per cent8.0−6.4
Regional war spillover S03Shock100 per cent18.3−15.4
Severe pandemic S10Shock100 per cent24.0−18.6
Market access opening S12Upside100 per cent24.0+11.6

Groups across simulations

Every capability group: its position, and its median and spread at the horizon across the simulations, with what the method spent on it.

73 of 73 groups

Capability group
Domain
1996
2026
Change
Levels invested
Credits
Energy TechnologiesCritical Technology7.9419.43 19.42 to 19.43+11.4912.77280
Resource InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure8.1919.35 19.34 to 19.35+11.1614.76387
Energy InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure11.0119.35 19.34 to 19.36+8.3412.35446
Technical & Vocational SkillsHuman Capital12.4419.94 19.93 to 19.94+7.5010.38115
Artificial IntelligenceCritical Technology9.2516.75 16.73 to 16.77+7.507.95155
Internal Security & OrderGovernance & Integrity14.7419.86 19.85 to 19.88+5.129.56354
Fiscal Capacity & Public FinanceFinancial Strength13.9918.93 18.88 to 18.99+4.948.54358
Robotics & Autonomous SystemsCritical Technology14.6519.58 19.20 to 19.90+4.934.36147
Water, Sanitation & Waste InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure15.1419.67 19.65 to 19.69+4.536.08207
Export Capability & SophisticationTrade & Investment15.0719.40 19.38 to 19.45+4.338.70358
Connectivity, Cyber & Trust TechnologiesCritical Technology15.7819.69 19.68 to 19.69+3.914.66147
Health System CapabilityHuman Capital16.1620.00 20.00 to 20.00+3.845.17157
Biotechnology & Health TechnologiesCritical Technology14.7618.09 17.83 to 18.25+3.334.21116
Financial Regulation & IntegrityFinancial Strength16.5219.48 19.47 to 19.48+2.966.66358
Alliances & Security CooperationInformation & Influence17.0719.36 19.03 to 19.68+2.293.0497
National Resilience & Crisis ManagementGovernance & Integrity17.4119.59 19.57 to 19.61+2.185.75354
Business Dynamism & EntrepreneurshipProduction & Innovation16.8118.87 18.82 to 18.91+2.063.15115
Semiconductors & Advanced ComputingCritical Technology14.7816.66 16.63 to 16.69+1.882.41115
Innovation & CommercialisationProduction & Innovation18.1219.26 19.13 to 19.39+1.141.75115
Advanced ManufacturingStrategic Infrastructure14.1214.90 14.65 to 15.40+0.780.000
Force Generation & MobilisationNational Security19.1319.48 19.18 to 19.63+0.350.2021
Land PowerNational Security19.4819.66 19.62 to 19.73+0.182.16354
Social InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure14.9415.00 14.68 to 15.10+0.060.000
Intelligence & AssessmentNational Security20.0020.00 19.85 to 20.000.002.08354
Air PowerNational Security20.0020.00 20.00 to 20.000.002.90475
Strategic Strike & Missile DefenceNational Security20.0020.00 20.00 to 20.000.003.83619
Agriculture & Food InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure15.4315.35 15.20 to 15.50−0.080.000
Space, Aerospace & Defence InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure17.1917.11 16.89 to 17.28−0.080.000
Research Talent & Knowledge CreationHuman Capital17.1417.04 16.95 to 17.11−0.100.000
Advanced EducationHuman Capital16.7616.64 16.57 to 16.73−0.120.000
Industrial & Sectoral BaseProduction & Innovation14.6314.51 14.27 to 14.77−0.120.000
Early Childhood DevelopmentHuman Capital15.7515.60 15.56 to 15.67−0.150.000
Population HealthHuman Capital15.4815.33 15.27 to 15.40−0.150.000
Regulatory Governance & Strategic ControlsGovernance & Integrity14.4314.14 14.14 to 14.15−0.290.000
Quantum TechnologiesCritical Technology5.244.90 4.89 to 4.92−0.340.000
Digital & AI CompetenceHuman Capital16.4816.13 16.10 to 16.14−0.350.000
Communications & Digital InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure16.3115.95 15.83 to 16.16−0.360.4511
Foundational EducationHuman Capital14.5514.18 14.12 to 14.26−0.370.000
Lifelong Learning & ReskillingHuman Capital14.1413.76 13.75 to 13.77−0.380.000
Advanced Materials & ManufacturingCritical Technology12.3411.86 11.76 to 11.98−0.480.000
Transparency, Oversight & AccountabilityGovernance & Integrity15.9215.44 15.44 to 15.45−0.480.000
Justice System & Fundamental RightsGovernance & Integrity15.5015.01 15.00 to 15.02−0.490.000
Political Institutions & Civic ParticipationGovernance & Integrity14.7914.29 14.28 to 14.30−0.500.000
Sovereign Capital & External Financial PowerFinancial Strength11.9711.46 11.22 to 11.65−0.510.000
Development Cooperation & Global AssistanceInformation & Influence13.0912.57 12.47 to 12.62−0.520.000
Cyber & Electromagnetic OperationsNational Security20.0019.47 19.46 to 19.48−0.532.72354
Public Integrity & Anti-CorruptionGovernance & Integrity13.7313.17 13.16 to 13.19−0.560.000
Nuclear DeterrenceNational Security17.8417.22 17.08 to 17.39−0.620.000
Space TechnologiesCritical Technology15.7515.09 15.07 to 15.10−0.660.000
Diaspora & Global CommunitiesInformation & Influence18.0717.40 17.40 to 17.40−0.670.000
Sensing, Timing & NavigationCritical Technology17.2716.55 16.53 to 16.57−0.720.000
Trade Policy & Market AccessTrade & Investment16.5315.78 15.33 to 17.83−0.750.9721
Financial InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure15.6414.88 14.81 to 14.92−0.760.000
Culture, Language & Education DiplomacyInformation & Influence10.9010.13 10.12 to 10.14−0.770.000
Transport InfrastructureStrategic Infrastructure12.5811.80 11.64 to 11.96−0.780.000
Information Environment & Strategic CommunicationInformation & Influence14.3913.61 13.48 to 13.67−0.780.000
Diplomatic Statecraft & Global NetworksInformation & Influence12.9112.12 12.10 to 12.14−0.790.000
Government Effectiveness & Public AdministrationGovernance & Integrity15.5314.73 14.69 to 14.83−0.800.000
Space OperationsNational Security18.3417.42 17.38 to 17.45−0.920.000
Technology Adoption & DiffusionProduction & Innovation16.4315.30 15.27 to 15.32−1.130.000
Digital & Services TradeTrade & Investment16.2915.13 15.11 to 15.15−1.160.000
Financial Stability & Crisis ManagementFinancial Strength17.5316.33 16.24 to 16.43−1.200.000
Monetary & Currency CapabilityFinancial Strength15.2314.02 13.88 to 14.12−1.210.000
Economic Output & ProductivityProduction & Innovation14.6613.41 13.37 to 13.47−1.250.000
Structural Transformation & ComplexityProduction & Innovation14.4113.16 12.90 to 13.29−1.250.000
Joint Command, Projection & SustainmentNational Security17.4516.05 15.99 to 16.12−1.400.000
Investment Attraction & ProjectionTrade & Investment14.9613.54 13.50 to 13.59−1.420.000
Global Value Chain PositionTrade & Investment16.5015.04 14.97 to 15.11−1.460.000
Financial System Depth & AccessFinancial Strength15.1913.70 13.70 to 13.71−1.490.000
Labour & EmploymentProduction & Innovation13.9512.42 12.35 to 12.55−1.530.000
Maritime PowerNational Security14.0412.39 12.38 to 12.41−1.650.000
Economic Leverage & DependenceTrade & Investment12.6010.89 10.66 to 11.09−1.710.000
Trade Facilitation & LogisticsTrade & Investment13.7911.31 11.28 to 11.35−2.480.000

Checks

The automated checks run on this experiment before anything was written about it. A warning is a candidate finding for the improvement loop.

  • passcredits_conservedlargest gap between credits in and credits accounted for: 3.4e-13
  • passscores_in_boundsscores range 4.887 to 20.000
  • passno_nans0 missing values in the trajectory and objectives
  • passprobe_replay_reproducesthe recorded moves played back reproduce the simulation to within 0.0e+00 points (10 simulations)
  • passledger_balancesthe edge ledger sums to the propagated change to within 1.0e-06 points
  • warnmove_without_shocklargest one-year move in a group with no shock landing: 4.45 points; 100% of simulations have one above 3
  • passtier_jumplargest gain in one domain within five years: 4 tiers (30 simulations above 2); tiers are reported, not an objective
  • passall_tier1_from_outside_top10starting rank 11; 0 simulations reach Tier 1 in all nine domains
  • warnsaturation_high100% of simulations end with a group at 20 that did not start there (median 2 groups)
  • passsaturation_low0% of simulations end with a group at 0 that did not start there (median 0 groups)
  • passspend_concentrationmedian concentration of spending across groups (HHI) 0.052; most funded group hard.national_security.strategic_strike_and_missile_defence
  • passsame_actionthe most repeated move (group and mode) appears in a median 20% of rounds
  • passregression_index_p50index_p50 moved 1.3% since cycle-002 (16.01 to 15.80); versions changed (0.1.0 to 0.1.1, graph 0.2.0 to 0.2.0)
  • passregression_score_sum_p50score_sum_p50 moved 1.2% since cycle-002 (1180.26 to 1165.87); versions changed (0.1.0 to 0.1.1, graph 0.2.0 to 0.2.0)

Settings and versions

Experiment cycle-003.e4-isr. Every simulation records the model, graph and parameter versions, the scenario, the method and its seed, so it can be reproduced exactly.

Nation
Israel (ISR)
Position
A reconstructed 1996 position, aligned to the Index's scale
Method
Scripted. Actions fixed in advance by the experiment: for a backcast, the nation's historical pathway.
Scenario
Scripted events: Global funding seizure in year 4, Regional war spillover in year 10, Global funding seizure in year 12, Regional war spillover in year 18, Severe pandemic in year 24, Market access opening in year 24, Regional war spillover in year 27
Objective
Capability index, the primary objective the experiment is judged on; every other objective is reported beside it
Horizon
30 rounds, 1996 to 2026
Simulations
30 seeds, 1 to 30. Every method in the batch faces the same draws for the same seed.
Graph elasticities
Drawn for each simulation, uniformly within each edge’s bracket
Income
Base credits 1,433.4 a round, moving with the economic groups
Versions
Model 0.2.0, Capability Dependency Graph 0.2.0, parameters 0.1.1
Batch
Backcast 1996-2026 (cycle-003), cycle 3 of the improvement loop
Runtime
7.2 seconds in all; 1501 microseconds a round
Not a forecast
Every figure is a distribution over the simulations of a structural model, reported to compare methods and test the model. None is a prediction of what a nation will do or become.
Structural parameters
Costs, decay, vulnerability and credits are structural seed values with low or medium confidence, set by domain with single-group exceptions. Five groups have no defensible value in a single-nation model and are flagged in the parameter tables.
Other nations are frozen
One nation is simulated at a time. Every other nation stays at its 2026 rating, so rank and tiers are measured against a still field; where the simulated nation rises past others their own tiers are not re-sorted.
Starting depth and mode are defaults
The position is the National Capability Index ratings. How institutionalised each capability is, and how much was built, bought or partnered, have no data behind them yet and start from structural defaults.
Credits are calibrated, not measured
Each nation’s income is set so that its position is affordable with headroom that rises with its fiscal capacity. It is not yet fiscal capacity as a share of GDP.